Background although potentially inappropriate medications pims have been linked to poor health outcomes, countryspecific pim criteria have not been compared. Originally conceived of in 1991 by the late mark beers, md, a geriatrician, the beers criteria catalogues medications that cause side effects in the elderly due to the physiologic changes of aging. The use of startstopp criteria for elderly patients in. Knowledge of pip prevalence should gear efforts to reduce the level of inappropriate prescriptions and may provide the need for developing national criteria. Explicit criteria as clinical tools to minimize inappropriate. Stopp start criteria as an intervention applied at a single time point during hospitalisation for acute illness in older people significantly improve medication appropriateness 7, an effect that is maintained 6 months postintervention. Beers criteria the beers criteria, initially developed by an expert consensus panel in 1991, are the most widely cited criteria used to assess inappropriate drug prescribing. The result was a paper published online in the lancet neurology on december 21, 2017, diagnosis of multiple sclerosis. Our aim was to detect older patients who were prescribed inappropriate drugs according to start stopp criteria in primary care. Stoppstart criteria for potential ip in older people recognise the dual nature of ip by including a list of pims stopp criteria and ppos start criteria. Screening tool of older peoples potentially inappropriate prescriptions.
Jun 01, 2018 they were originally proposed in 2008 and were updated in 2014. Diagnostic criteria were established, to help inform evidencebased recommendations likely to speed the diagnostic process and reduce the incidence of misdiagnosis. A new approach to detecting potentially inappropriate prescribing in old age author links open overlay panel d. Application of the stoppstart criteria to a medical. Subscriptions offer access to a range of resources, from a. The american geriatric society has updated the beers criteria list based on evidencebased recommendations. American geriatrics society 2019 updated ags beers. Potentially inappropriate medications according to stoppj. Start screening tool to action right treatment a new explicit evidence based screening tool to detect prescribing omissions in elderly patients. Stopp criteria screening tool of older persons potentially inappropriate prescriptions the stopp criteria are significantly associated with adverse drug events in older people with an acute illness. First full paper on start criteria start screening tool to alert doctors to the right. We then identified the target for whom these criteria would be.
Implementation of stoppstart criteria in different settings. Pdf stoppstart criteria for potentially inappropriate. Patients aged over 65, admitted to health center no. The algorithms were applied to a dutch primary care database, including patients aged. Evaluation of clarity of the stoppstart criteria for. Twentyfour criteria were deemed to be most relevant 22 measures of potentially inappropriate medications and two measures of. Objectives to provide baseline information on inappropriate prescribing ip, and to evaluate whether potentially inappropriate medications pims, as defined by stopp screening tool of older persons potentially inappropriate prescriptions criteria, were associated with preventable adverse drug events ades andor hospitalization. Criteriosstoppstartgrupo3,alma20leonor zapata altamirano mexico marcela mar meza peru vitor jorge woytuski brasil brasil fabiana giber argentina. For this study, the supplementary data of the corrigendum of the stoppstart criteria v. Potentially inappropriate medications defined by stopp. The following prescriptions are potentially inappropriate to use in patients aged 65 years and older. Potentially inappropriate medications defined by stopp criteria and the risk of adverse drug events in older hospitalized patients arch intern med. American geriatrics society 2019 updated ags beers criteria. Draft stoppfrail criteria the authors, all of whom have recognised expertise in geriatric pharmacotherapy, compiled the initial draft of stoppfrail indicators and arranged them according to physiological systems, similar to stopp start criteria.
In a recent study, 53 of the stopp start criteria were deemed compatible with the u. The stopp screening tool of older persons potentially inappropriate prescriptions and start screening tool to alert doctors to right treatment criteria, now in its 2 nd version, present a renewed approach to address some of these concerns. Potentially inappropriate medications for older people. Help tm provides the latest tools and handson guidance to make delirium prevention a reality. Chemical atc codes for medication and international classification of primary care icpc codes for diagnoses. King, pharmd clinical pharmacist lecom health starting and stopping medications in the elderly objectives explain concepts of altered pharmacokinetics in the elderly understand drug related problems in the elderly. Stoppfrail screening tool of older persons prescriptions.
Objectives to analyse the applicability of the stoppstart criteria as a tool to identify patients with potentially inappropriate medications pim during pharmaceutical validation of prescriptions in a longterm care hospital, to identify risk factors for pim and to characterise the physiological systems and drugs more frequently associated with these pim. Ortho tm is an evidencebased geriatricsorthopedics comanagement model that can be implemented throughout your health system. Twentyfour criteria were deemed to be most relevant 22 measures of. Elderly, psychotropic drugs, antidepressants, screening tool, inappropriate medications, potentially. Early hospital readmission is a common problem among geriatric patients, as they are more susceptible to adverse drug events, which are associated with increased hospital admission. In a recent study, 53 of the stoppstart criteria were deemed compatible with the u. The operation that you have selected will move away from the current results page, your download options will not persist. Application of the stoppstart criteria to a medical record. The updated report was published in the journal of the american geriatric society. For potentially inappropriate medication use in older adults from the american geriatrics society this clinical tool, based on the ags 2012 updated beers criteria for potentially inappropriate medication use in older adults ags 2012 beers criteria, has been developed to assist healthcare providers in improving medication safety in older adults. Numerous explicit prescribing tools aim to guide clinicians on cessation of pims including beers, stopp start and forta criteria. A list of potentially inappropriate medications pim s was developed and published by mark h. September 2014 page 6 gastrointestinal system bnf section 1 stopp diphenoxylate cophenotrope, loperamide or codeine phosphate for treatment of diarrhoea of unknown cause.
It consists of a series of rulessuggestions related to highyield problems in prescribing for older people, both in terms of reducing medication burden stopp and adding in potentially benefical therapy start author. Stopp screening tool of older persons potentially inappropriate prescriptions. Oct 16, 2014 stoppstart criteria for potentially inappropriate prescribing in older people. Stopp start criteria for potentially inappropriate prescribing in older people. To describe and compare the main pharmacological groups involved and determine the factors associated with the detection of pip in these patients. The following drug prescriptions are potentially inappropriate in persons aged. The stopp screening tool of older persons prescriptions and start screening tool to alert to right treatment criteria were designed and validated as explicit criteria to help clinicians detect common instances of potentially inappropriate medicines pims and potential prescribing omissions ppos. This project was a collaboration between misl, cork constraint computation centre and the ucc school of pharmacy. Beers criteria had no comparable recommendations for the 2 start criteria. Therefore, with the accepted need for deprescribing in the frail older population, there is a clear associated need for speci.
December 21, 2017 national multiple sclerosis society. Stopp start criteria for potential ip in older people recognise the dual nature of ip by including a list of pims stopp criteria and ppos start criteria. Thus, we compared the identification of pims between the screening tool for older persons appropriate prescriptions for japanese stopp j and the 2015 american geriatrics society beers criteria in elderly patients receiving home. Stopp version 2 consists of 80 imu criteria outlining clinical circumstances where specific, commonly encountered medications or medication classes are considered potentially inappropriate in older people. Beers and colleagues for nursing home residents in 1991 and was subsequently expanded and revised to include all settings of geriatric care. October 2017 trinity college dublin, the university of dublin phd thesis 20062009. This can sometimes lead to harm rather than benefit from a particular treatment.
There is substantial overlap between the stoppstart criteria and beers criteria in the context of a nh population. The creation, development, reliability, and use of these criteria in routine practice is described and discussed. Methods we prospectively studied older patients n 301. October 2017 trinity college dublin, the university of dublin phd thesis 20062009, university college cork appropriate prescribing for older people. However, these comprehensive tools are designed to detect common and preventable pims in the general older population and not specifically in frailer people with limited life expectancy. Criteria catalogues medications that cause side effects in the elderly due to the physiologic changes of aging.
Screening tools for geriatric medicine prescription. Oct 16, 2017 the stopp screening tool of older persons potentially inappropriate prescriptions and start screening tool to alert doctors to right treatment criteria, now in its 2 nd version, present a renewed approach to address some of these concerns. The ags beers criteria is an explicit list of pims that are typically best avoided by older adults in most circumstances or under speci. Feb, 2019 the use of stoppstart to screen and address imu in europe, asia, north america, south america, africa and australia suggests that the criteria have global relevance. View the 2012 pdf here, along with rationale for why the medications might be inappropriate and the strength of the recommendation based on available research. There is substantial overlap between the stopp start criteria and beers criteria in the context of a nh population. The criteria are a list of medications considered potentially inappropriate for use in older patients, mostly due to high risk for adverse events. In 2015, the ags again funded the development of the updated criteria using an evidence. Stopp screening tool of older persons prescriptions and start screening tool to alert doctors to right i. Stopp start criteria as an intervention applied at a single time point during hospitalisation for acute illness in older people significantly improve medication appropriateness, an effect that is maintained 6 months postintervention. Stoppstart criteria for potentially inappropriate prescribing in older people. The stopp start project was made possible thanks to.
The ags cocare programs provide you with tools, resources, education, and support. Greenberg, phd, rn, gnpbc, the hartford institute for geriatric nursing, new york university rory meyers college of nursing issue number 16, revised 2019 why. The 2017 18 general practice contract sets out the requirements in england for frailty as follows. These data show that stopp criteria are more relevant than beers criteria in defining pims in older people presenting to hospital with acute illness. King, pharmd clinical pharmacist lecom health starting and stopping medications in the elderly objectives explain concepts of altered pharmacokinetics in the elderly understand drug related problems in the elderly discuss strategies for minimization of drug related problems in the elderly. Stoppfrail screening tool of older persons prescriptions in. The 2019 american geriatrics society updated beers. Since the first iteration of stopp start criteria in 2008, our research group has shown a number of important properties of stopp start criteria, namely. Oct 16, 2014 stopp start criteria for potential ip in older people recognise the dual nature of ip by including a list of pims stopp criteria and ppos start criteria. Oct 22, 2019 the modified stopp start criteria for sri lanka consisted of 105 criteria, including 70 stopp criteria and 35 start criteria after two delphi validation rounds and a final meeting held with the participation of all experts to resolve disagreements and to establish 100% consensus. Stopp criteria identified more pip than beers criteria.
Screening tool of older persons prescriptions stopp version 2. Our aim was to test computerized algorithms for applying these criteria to a medical record database. Stopp screening tool of older persons prescriptions start screening tool to alert doctors to right treatment. Stopp start criteria have been shown to improve medication appropriateness 25, 26 and reduce the incidence of adverse drug reactions in hospitalised older adults. Objectives to compare potentially inappropriate prescribing pip according to the clinical judgement of the pharmacist with pip according to explicit stopp start criteria in institutionalised and hospitalised patients with multiple pathologies. Stopp start criteria as an intervention applied within 72 h of admission significantly reduce adrs. Click export csv or ris to download the entire page or use the checkboxes to select a subset of records to download.
Stopp start tool in older people to identify potential inappropriate medicati on stopp criteria and potential prescribing omissions start criteria for those on multiple medicines or with long term conditions. Stoppstart tool in older people to identify potential inappropriate medicati on stopp criteria and potential prescribing omissions start criteria for those on multiple medicines or with long term conditions. Furthermore, stopp criteria do not suggest discontinuing major drugs classes that are least likely to have bene. For this study, the supplementary data of the corrigendum of the stopp start criteria v. Potentially inappropriate prescriptions for elderly people. The files of the subjects were surveyed retrospectively for the final one year in the digital environment, using the family medicine information system. Pdf stopp screening tool of older persons potentially. The stopp start project developed constraintbased software screening tools which can be used to improve the quality and safety of medicine prescriptions for elderly patients. Inappropriate prescribing defined by stopp and start criteria. The objective is to examine the association between exposure to potentially inappropriate medications under selected stopp version 2 criteria related to drugdisease interactions and unplanned early hospitalization. They also suggest that pims, as defined by stopp criteria, are significantly associated with serious ades, contrary to the findings of onder et al. Stopp places special emphasis on potential adverse drugdrug. Results for start stopp checklist 1 10 of 17 sorted by relevance date.
905 738 725 1544 79 1526 36 500 114 1347 1093 1634 655 541 1132 930 302 580 1055 839 496 1489 1252 367 993 778 1434 171 222 1278 539 208